Comparison · Updated October 31, 2026
Generator marketing agencies, compared
Every route to generator leads sells you the same word, marketing, and delivers a different thing. This page compares the five routes installers actually use, on the questions that decide whether the leads turn into installs. Where a number appears, it's ours, from the campaigns we run. Where a route isn't ours, we tell you what to ask instead of inventing figures for someone else's business.
01 · The five routes
Five ways to buy generator marketing
| Question | Lead marketplaces | Generalist local agency | Generator specialist (DarkHorse) | Manufacturer programs | Do it yourself |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who else gets the lead | Other installers buy the same lead | Depends on the agency, ask who else they run in your territory | Nobody. One installer per territory, never resold | Dealers share the manufacturer's pool or listing | Nobody, if the ads are yours |
| Whose name the homeowner sees | The marketplace's | Yours | Yours, with videos of your own team | The manufacturer's, then yours | Yours |
| Who follows up, and how fast | You, against every other buyer of that lead | Usually you | Automated follow-up is set up with the campaign, and your team calls | You | You, whenever you get to it |
| How you pay | Per lead, shared or exclusive tiers | Retainer plus ad spend, usually | Ad spend plus a management fee, with a 90-day lead guarantee | Program terms set by the manufacturer | Ad spend plus your own hours |
| What it asks of your team | Fast calling, every time | Approvals and assets, varies | Three short videos a month, filmed on your phone from our scripts | Program requirements and training | Everything: creative, targeting, follow-up, reporting |
The marketplace and manufacturer rows have their own detailed pages on this site: lead marketplaces for generator installers and Generac PowerPlay leads. The generalist and do it yourself rows describe the route in general, not any one company.
02 · The cost question
What the specialist route costs, in the open
Most agencies, us included, won't publish a management fee on a page like this, because the fee follows the plan. What we can publish is the ad spend side, because we measure it across every installer we run. In our Meta campaigns the typical installer paid $53.57 a lead in ad spend, and the pooled cost across all installers was $53.04. Both figures count ad spend per Meta lead, qualified or not.
Use those two numbers on any route you're quoted. If a marketplace lead costs about the same as an exclusive lead from your own ads, the shared lead has to close at the same rate just to break even, and it usually doesn't, because you're one of several installers calling. The exclusive vs shared math, worked through.
And hold every provider, us included, to the same definition of a lead. Ours is the agreement's: the homeowner is in your service area, has a $10,000+ budget, wants it within 6 months and is actually asking about a generator. The four tests, in full.
03 · Before you sign
Six questions that sort any agency out
- Do you run another installer in my territory? If the answer is yes, or vague, your ads bid against their other client's ads and your leads aren't a system, they're a split.
- What counts as a lead, in writing? Area, budget, timeline and intent, or just a form with a phone number. The definition decides what you'll actually pay for.
- What happens if you miss the number? Our answer is backend protection: you pay upfront, and if we miss the number we keep working with no management fee until it's hit. Ask every agency what theirs is.
- Who makes the ads, and who is in them? Homeowners hire the crew they see. Stock photos and a logo convert like it.
- How fast do leads get called, and by whom? A lead system that ends at the form is half a system. The follow-up plan should be part of the pitch, not an afterthought.
- What will I see every two weeks? Cost per lead with the counting method stated, booked estimates, and what changed since last time. If the report is impressions and reach, it's hiding the part that matters.
04 · The short version
Which route fits which installer
Marketplaces fit an installer who needs a few extra jobs and can call instantly, every time. A generalist fits a shop that wants one local vendor for everything and isn't betting the season on generators. A manufacturer program is a good extra for any dealer, and a thin only source, because you don't control its volume or its rules. Do it yourself fits an owner who will genuinely spend the hours every week, and most owners won't by month three. A specialist fits an installer who wants a steady flow of qualified leads under their own name, one installer per territory, with the lead count guaranteed in writing.
Whichever route you pick, check the territory question first if it's us: we run one installer per territory, so the slot is either open or it isn't. Check your territory or book a strategy call.
05 · FAQ
Questions about choosing an agency
How do I choose a generator marketing agency?
Ask five things. Will another installer in your territory get the same leads? What exactly counts as a lead? Who calls the leads, and how fast? What happens if the lead count is missed? And what will the reporting show: cost per lead, booked estimates, or installs? The answers separate a lead system from a monthly retainer with ads attached.
Should I hire a generalist agency or a generator specialist?
A generalist can run competent ads for many trades, and that breadth is fine for a simple local campaign. A specialist brings the things that are specific to this job: what a qualified generator lead is, what installers actually pay per lead, which offers homeowners answer, and how seasonal this demand is. Judge either one on those specifics, not on the pitch.
How long should I give a marketing agency before judging the results?
Longer than a month. In our campaigns, the typical installer's cost per lead in the first 30 days was $52.53 against $51.07 after day 30, across 10 installers we could compare on both sides. Month one is a test month for creative, offers and follow-up, whichever route you pick.
What will a generator specialist charge per lead?
We don't charge per lead. In ad spend, the typical generator installer in our Meta campaigns paid $53.57 a lead, plus our management fee, and we go through the fee on the strategy call. Every cost here is ad spend per Meta lead, qualified or not.
More · For generator installers
Keep reading
Is your territory still open?
We run one generator installer per territory. Book a strategy call and we'll check yours, map local demand and show you the math.
Bring everyone who signs off on marketing: your partner, spouse or co-owner.